- Indigo Augustine 1
- Indya Mirales 1
- Ingrid Sexy Dirty Girl 1
- Ionie Luvcoxx 1
- Ippei Nakata 1
- Irina Cage 1
- Irina Pavlova 2
- Irinag 1
- Iris Argent 1
- Iron Biker 1
- IronDick 1
- Isabel Ice 1
- Isabela Avila 1
- Isabella Chrystin 1
- Isabella Clark 2
- Isabella Della 1
- Isabella Nice 1
- Isabella Pacino 1
- Isabella Stanza 1
- Isabelle Miller 1
- Isiah Maxwell 4
- Isis Love 3
- Isla 1
- Isla Biza 1
- Its Cleo 1
- Ivana Jones 1
- Ivana Sugar 4
- Ivi Rein 2
- Ivy Lebelle 4
- Ivy Rose 2
- Ivy Wolfe 1
- Ivy Young 1
- Izi Ashley 2
- Izzy Lush 2
- J Cool 1
- J Mac 12
- Jack Blaque 2
- Jack Kallahari 2
- Jack Lawrence 1
- Jack Napier 2
- Jack Rippher 1
- Jack Vegas 5
- Jacky Lawless 1
- Jackylafey 1
- Jaclyn Taylor 1
- Jada Fire 4
- Jada Sparks 1
- Jada Stevens 15
- Jade Dylan 1
- Jade Jantzen 2
- Jade Kimiko 2
- Jade Kush 2
- Jade Nile 2
- Jade Valentine 1
- Jade Wilde 1
- JadeKink 2
- JadeMercury 2
- Jadilica 1
- Jai Sean 1
- Jake Adams 2